Skip to content

20 minutes to see if we're a fit.

Book 20 minutes

Guide

Fractional CMO vs. Agency vs. In-House Hire: Which Is Right?

The short answer

An in-house hire gives you one person full time. An agency gives you a team that carries out the work, usually directed by you. A fractional CMO or fractional team gives you senior leadership and hands-on work part time, without a full-time salary. Many growing companies start fractional and hire in-house once the plan is proven.

Side by side

In-house hireAgencyFractional team
Who sets strategyYour hireUsually youSenior leader on the team
Who does the workYour hire, plus vendorsAgency staffThe same senior team
How you paySalary and benefitsRetainer or project feesMonthly agreement
Time to startMonths to recruitWeeksWeeks
Best forLong-term, steady needsLarge volumes of one kind of workSenior strategy plus execution

In-house hire

Good when you know exactly what you need and it won't change. One person can't be an expert in strategy, search, content, ads and reporting, so most in-house marketers still hire outside help.

Traditional agency

Good for producing a lot of one type of work. Watch for the senior people from the pitch handing your account to junior staff, and reports that count activity instead of results.

Fractional CMO or fractional team

Good when you need senior thinking and hands-on work but aren't ready for a full-time executive. It works best when someone inside your company owns the relationship and can make decisions quickly.

Questions to help you choose

  • Do we need a plan, or do we already have one and need hands to carry it out?
  • Can one person cover every skill we need?
  • How fast do we need to start?
  • Who will report results to leadership, and how?

Where Tillit fits

Tillit works as a fractional, senior-led team. We set the plan, do the work and report results in one simple report. We plug into in-house teams or agencies.

If You Want Marketing You Can Easily Explain, Let's Talk.

We work best with leadership teams who want fewer distractions, clearer decisions and growth that holds up under pressure.

Book a Strategy Call

We reply within one business day.